Meaningful Compensation Essay.
Read “Legalizing the Organ Trade?” by Ritter, located on the Time website (copy and paste the link into the URL).
As noted in Peter Ritter’s (2008), “Legalizing the Organ Trade?”, Singapore’s health minister, Khaw Boon Wan, argued that, “We may be able to find an acceptable way to allow a meaningful compensation for some living, unrelated kidney donors, without breaching ethical principles or hurting the sensitivities of others” (para. 2). In the definition essay assignment, you are asked to select a term, define the term, and offer evidence to support your definition of the term.Meaningful Compensation Essay.
In this case, imagine you have selected the term meaningful compensation to define. You might ask yourself: What constitutes meaningful compensation for an organ donor, especially if the donor is poor and the recipient is wealthy? What examples of human organ sales can I find that match or do not match your definition of meaningful compensation? What other terms related to organ sales and donation would be suitable for an argument of definition?Meaningful Compensation Essay.
The demand for organs to do transplants and save lives has surpassed the supply in a way that increases the desperation of patients and teams that conduct transplants. According to Bastani (2015), improved rates of survival and expanding the indications of transplants has worsened this shortage. Lack of donors has made some patients go to the extent of contracting organ brokers to purchase organs from living donors. As emphasized by Friedman (2006), since organ payment is illegal in most countries including the United States, most donors and families can only talk of meaningful compensation thus, the process should be legalized.Meaningful Compensation Essay.
It is difficult to determine a specific definition of the term meaningful compensation since there are uncertainties that surround organ donation such as adverse outcomes of the surgical procedure, early and late complications that the donor might experience. Besides donation situations differ from one person to another. However, from the perspective of a close relative or family member, meaningful compensation is an action that benefits both parties. For instance, a parent can donate an organ to his/her child, which ultimately saves the child's life. In this context, the child will have an improved health status and the family will have a liberalized lifestyle and can save additional healthcare costs that could be used on the child’s management.Meaningful Compensation Essay.
An additional term associated with organ sales is involuntary. Although there is limited evidence that explains the likelihood of exploitation of paid donors who benefit minimally from the supposed financial compensation. Selling organs increases unfairness and susceptibility to exploitation (Gordon et al., 2015). This particularly affects donors who are directly affected by finances. These donors are likely to be manipulated, persecuted or blackmailed by organ brokers or recipients. In extreme cases, involuntary organ donation may involve the stealing of organs.Meaningful Compensation Essay.